How to Stand Out in Facebook Referral Threads [Alumni Check-In #7] (Episode 81)
If you've ever responded to a Facebook referral thread only to watch your comment get buried beneath dozens of others, this episode is for you. In this alumni check-in, Anna answers a question from Confident Copy graduate Ellie about how therapists can stand out in Facebook groups, listservs, and other referral spaces without sounding like everyone else.
Rather than relying on generic responses or dropping a website link and hoping for the best, Anna shares a practical framework for writing referral responses that communicate why you're the right fit. By focusing on specificity, clarity, and connection, you'll learn how to make it easier for both therapists and potential clients to recognize your expertise—and choose you with confidence.
Here’s what you’ll learn in this episode:
1️⃣ Why generic referral responses get overlooked—and what to do instead.
2️⃣ The four-part framework Anna uses to craft referral responses that stand out.
3️⃣ How mirroring the referral request helps build trust and demonstrate you're the right fit.
4️⃣ Why knowing your niche and having the right language ready before you need it makes all the difference.
-
Hi, everyone. Welcome back to Marketing Therapy. This is our seventh alumni check-in of the year. So our alumni check-ins, if you're not familiar, are opportunities for our Confident Copy alumni, so folks who graduate our Confident Copy program, to ask questions about their marketing as they move on from the program.
So we've talked about things like how to differentiate yourself, how to pick images on your website, whatever that might be, and today's question is so good and so relevant no matter where you find yourself in private practice, and it's how to stand out in places like Facebook referral threads. You know what I'm talking about, right?
You log into Facebook, or you hop onto your local listserv, whatever that might be, and someone's asking for a referral to a therapist, and literally by the time you finish typing a response, there are fifty other therapists who are allegedly the perfect fit for that person, right? That's what we're tackling today. So, Ellie is a graduate of our Confident Copy program, and she said, "I am in many Facebook and networking groups, but with so many people looking for clients, it's hard to stand out and get clients to see your website." So she asked us, "How do you stand out when you are a perfect fit but fifty people respond that they are also a great fit, whether they are or not?"
Have you felt this? I bet you have 'cause, like I said, this is a really common experience for most people in private practice. And it's something that I have talked about and coached people on independently but never actually taught on, so I'm happy that Ellie asked this question, and I'm happy to get to dive into this today.
Now, the painful thing about this is you could actually be the perfect fit for that person, for that person, you might be exactly who they need, right? You could be able to get them exactly where they want to go in the exact type of style and experience that they're looking for, but you could still lose out to someone who's a worse fit but a better communicator.
This comes down to your language. The way that you're gonna stand out in these referral threads or in similar environments is with your language. So this isn't so much about how do you compete with fifty people, but how do you make it obvious that you might actually be the right one, right? How do you stand out in that sea of sameness we've been talking about so much?
Now, I do wanna let you know that doors to our Confident Copy live cohort, the next one and the last one of 2027, are opening next week.
If that's something you have been thinking about, if you listen to this episode and you're like, "Wow, I need help figuring out who I'm the right fit for and how to communicate that," that's exactly what Confident Copy does. The wait list is going to be closing at the end of this week. Doors are opening next week, so this is the time to be jumping onto that wait list, walkerstrategyco.com/waitlist.
You qualify for an exclusive discount that we're not offering publicly. But let's get into this. How do you stand out on these Facebook referral threads? This is ultimately the sea of sameness I've been talking about in the wild. This is exactly where we see the fact that people, whether that's another therapist or a client themselves, is wading through this list, this sea, this group of people who say they're the right fit, but who are all also saying pretty much the exact same thing.
How do you stand out? I see so many people just drop a URL and run in these situations like, "Oh, I'm a good fit." Drop y- website URL, never think about it again. I want you to approach this differently. Because when 50 people are responding to these ISO posts, most of them are essentially interchangeable. So really what this comes down to is just you doing things a little bit differently. Okay? Now, there are two things you need to have in place before you ever respond here. You have to know these two things.
You have to know who you're the right fit for. Now, you probably could help most people, right, that someone is looking for a therapist for, but you know who you're the right fit for. You know what types of people you want on your caseload and who you don't.
Okay? So you have to have a really deep understanding of that. You've gotta know what qualities you're looking for, what presenting issues, what demographics, whatever that might be. You've gotta know who you're the right fit for, and then you have to have language for what you do and what makes you different.
That's the only way that you're gonna rise above that sea of sameness here. You need to know this in advance. You cannot see one of these posts on a Tuesday afternoon and suddenly drum up why you're different and why you're the right fit for this person. You have to have a really deep understanding of who you're talking to, what you offer, and what makes you different.
These are fundamental things that cannot, like I said, happen in a moment. If you are figuring out your fit, if you're fishing for words while you're typing that reply, it's gonna show, and you've probably already lost the 30 seconds that, you know, 15 other people are dropping their responses in. This has to be built before.
This is something you have to become very, very comfortable with and secure in, and you've gotta know how to communicate it. This is a really good example of what we call your client conversion engine. There's three pieces to this if you're not familiar with the framework that we build our Confident Copy program on.
But we have first there's confident identity. So this is knowing your right fit. This is knowing what you bring to the table specifically. Okay? Not in those vague like safe space or compassionate terms, but specifically what sets you apart. The second piece of that client conversion engine is what we call confident presence.
So that's the language for your identity. Okay? It's available to you the second you need it, whether that's your website or Facebook thread, whatever that might be. It's actually showing up with that identity and communicating it. And then there's the confident connection. It's using that language in that moment of contact.
Right? That's what this exercise is all about.
So that means that confident connection, that ability to go out and potentially get that client only works if your identity and your presence are already solid. You've already gotta know who you're the right fit for, and you've gotta have the language for what sets you apart and who you're trying to attract
If you find yourself improvising- Mm-hmm ... like so many people are when they're responding to these things, that's when you end up reading generic. That's when you end up just dropping your URL because you can't think of what else to say And if you just did a little bit of this pre-work, you would enter into this with a lot more understanding and a lot more language ready.
Because again, the reason you're going to stand out comes down to your language. You don't have anything else working for you here except for what you choose to say. Okay? Now, I do wanna note here that I think while this question was asked around the concept of those Facebook ISO posts, I think that this approach can be used in multiple scenarios. You know, I'm in the Nashville Moms group, for instance, and I think there's like, I don't know, 30,000 moms or something like that in that group, and I don't even interact in that group super often, but each week I see at least three to four people requesting referrals for themselves or for their relationships or for their children.
And that's obviously a little bit different because it's not a therapist asking a bunch of other therapists for referrals, but it's still an opportunity for you to get specific if, if that were to be something you were gonna respond to, an opportunity to be specific, an opportunity to set yourself apart, to give a little bit of taste of what it is that you do, rather than just saying, "Oh yeah, I can do that."
Like, okay, there's a difference between being able to do something and showing it, right? And inviting someone into it. So perhaps the approach I'm going to give you in this episode could be used for other places, right? The Listserv email you get, the, the Facebook group for therapists, or the Facebook group for your ideal client.
Maybe this could be used elsewhere. So I invite you to consider that, not just for this one specific scenario, but others where you're being asked to state what it is that makes you different and to offer your, your services to someone who very likely may be the perfect fit for your caseload. So in order to prepare for this episode, what I did is jump into a couple of the Facebook groups I'm in, and actually pull some real life ISOs.
These are anonymized, but I wanted to actually pull real life posts. What are people out there looking for? How are people responding? That kind of thing. So as I do this, I wanna give you a framework for how to think about responding to these, okay?
And this framework is kind of four pieces. Now, it's packed into, I don't know, a handful of sentences. But first and foremost is I want you to mirror the specific ask that you see here. And like I said, I'm gonna walk through some examples, but I want you to mirror back a detail or two that shows you read the dang thing, okay?
You are not just doing the URL drop and run thing. I want you to show that you are mapping what it is that you are responding to what is being asked of you. Then I want to state your match, the fact that you're the right fit, as a fact, okay? Whether that is logistics, just that you're available when this person needs, or you are a similar demographic, whatever that might be.
Your identity, your fit, whatever, but state it as a fact. You do this. I specialize in this. This is exactly what I do. State it as a fact. Keep it to two to four sentences. Okay? We cannot afford for you to go on and on and on and on. This is not a bulleted list. This is not a dissertation.
This is exactly why you're the right fit condensed into just a skimmable response. And then always invite the next step. What is the next step for you? Is that texting? Is that booking a consultation on your website? Is that dropping an email? Be explicit about what needs to happen next. Don't assume that that therapist is, is going to know.
Oftentimes, these therapists are going to take this list and provide it back to the client, or sometimes the therapist is going to choose exactly who they're going to refer, okay? So in this case, I want you to be really, really clear about what you wanna see that person do next.
Okay, so the framework again, one, you're gonna mirror the specific ask. Two, you're gonna state your match as fact. Three, you're gonna keep it short, two to four sentences max. And then four, you're always gonna invite the next step. One other thing before we get into these examples. I want you to consider what is going to matter to the therapist as they make decisions about who to include in their list, and also to the client when they're making a decision about who to reach out to.
What might they value, and how does your approach, your setup, your offerings, your specializations align with those values? So sinking down into the shoes of that therapist who's making the decision, of the client who's making the decision, and using that to inform your response. Okay? All right, let's look at example number one.
Male adult client, prefers a female therapist. Very successful at work despite some frustrating challenges, but a lot of difficulty with dating. Super goal-oriented, responds well to a really frank approach, learning how to manage anger. This is a really in-depth post. I know they're not all like this.
But a really cool example of lots of things we can find that the therapist and the client are likely to value, right? Lots of opportunities for mirroring. So a really generic response would be, "Hi, I work with men and have openings. Feel free to reach out." Like, okay. And there were versions of that on this exact thread where I pulled this from.
Here's an example of a specific response, if we're using that four-step framework: "I work with a lot of high-achieving guys struggling in career and dating. I have a very direct and no-fluff style and do a lot of anger work as well. Have room right now. Have him text me," and included the number. That's an example of something that's going to stand out.
So we mirrored a couple of things, right? We mirrored the high achieving, the career, the dating, the anger, the direct style, and gave a really clear next step. It was concise, but it was also a little bit more in-depth than just, "Hey, I can do that," or, "I would be a good fit." Like, okay, then I'm just taking your word at it.
Show me. Okay? That was a great example of showing. All right, let's look at another one. Recommendations for a couples therapy in X city. They're dealing with challenges related to having young kids that are autistic. All right? So we know a couple of things we could be mirroring back here, right?
Couples, city you know, neurodivergence young kids, that kind of thing. We can probably assume that the specific intersection of couples work and parenting is gonna matter. Certainly neurodivergent-affirming care is gonna be huge here, so not just being a couples therapist, right? So a generic response would be, "Hey, I, I'm a couples therapist in that city."
Great. Okay, a specific response here would be, "I often work with couples who are parents of young children and have a lot of experience with neurodivergence in children.
Perhaps you even have some lived experience with that. I actually have neurodivergent children myself."
Here's a link to my website, and perhaps a link to your parenting page or your neurodivergence page of your website. You know, would love to schedule a consult, whatever that might be. Again, we're mirroring back specific things. We're stating your match as fact, what it is that you do that aligns, keeping it short, and inviting that next step.
All right, let's look at another one. This one I SO an African American therapist who is skilled in couples work. Couple is needing weekend or Thursday or Friday evening appointments via telehealth. Okay, so this one's a little bit more logistical. Certain availability is required, also seeking a particular identity as, as it relates to being an African American.
Don't necessarily know what they're looking for or what they're wanting help with, but enough to, to be able to mirror back. So we want both kind of an identity match but also some logistics here. So a specific response here might be, "I'm a BIPOC therapist specializing in couples work. I have Thursday evening and weekend openings right now."
Feel free to provide my website and here's my number if they prefer to text me. Okay, so we mirrored back. We stated as fact where the values or the needs lined up. We gave us a next step. All right, one last one. This one was really short. Looking for a therapist to help a client process traumatic birth.
Okay. Not a ton of information, but certainly enough to know if this is likely to be a right fit for you, okay? So this isn't just generic trauma. We're looking for some real specialization that's going to matter to this person. So a response might be, " I work specifically with birth trauma and love supporting moms in this. I do EMDR and other trauma-informed work as well
Here's a link you're welcome to share with a client. Maybe that it, again, is a link to that specific page on your website. I've got openings as soon as next week." All right, so we're seeing a little bit of that logistics lineup or kind of some, some urgency related to availability as well as your specialties and how that aligns with the values of, of the therapist and of the client.
So there you go. Those are some ways to think through and approach responses. Again, gonna take a little bit longer than the 10 seconds it will take to copy and paste your website URL, but holy cow, is there opportunity for you to stand above the noise in these threads.
Now, the other thing to note is, of course, not every single one of these is going to be the right fit. Can I encourage you that if you read something and you're like, "That's not me," but it reminds you of someone you do know, please refer that person in that post. I've heard such fantastic things from therapists who make a practice of referring to their colleagues or kind of cheering on, essentially other clinicians that they know. So if you don't do couples work but you see a post about it and your colleague or someone you know does this work, tag them, mention them, do something like that.
Even if it never gets back to them, there's just something really wonderful about putting that out into the world. And if you know that they're likely to be a good fit, then that is in service to the therapist, that is in service to the client and it's also in service to you for the good juju and the reciprocity that can come from actions like that.
So I encourage you to keep that in mind, even if this isn't someone that you yourself would like to see. All right, so that is how you stand out. Like I said, this comes down to your language. Your ability to stand out in these scenarios comes down to the words you use, how you use them, where you use them, and how those words distinguish you from other people who might say they are the right fit and as Ellie said, may or may not be.
We don't even know. And so don't make the person making this post take your word for it. Show them. Mirror back why you're the right fit. Say specifically. Take a little bit more time to craft this response, and you are very, very likely to see a lot more come from this. Now, are you still gonna be competing with a bunch of other people?
Absolutely. Are there certainly other people that could serve that client well? Absolutely. But by taking this approach, you are going to be increasing your chances of getting in front of someone who is very likely to be a fantastic fit for you. Ellie, I can speak directly to you knowing that you're doing a really great job of this. We were able to develop Ellie's branding and help her launch a new website along with copy, and we have heard from her how people have just resonated really, really deeply with what it is that we have done for her, and I know that people are seeing what it is that she's doing and, and resonating with it.
And I hope that this framework for those Facebook referral threads and other scenarios is useful for you, Ellie, but also to everyone listening, whether you are a Confident Copy alumni or not. Now, if you're not a Confident Copy alumni, you should be. If you're the right fit for the program, of course. But as I mentioned at the top of the episode, the wait list for our next cohort is closing at the end of this week.
When you sign up for the wait list, there is no obligation. I only want you to jump in if this is the right next step for you. But you will lock in an exclusive discount that will not be available publicly. You'll also get early access next week when the cohort opens, immediate access to the entire curriculum, and then we'll kick off later in August as a group, and you'll get 16 weeks of live coaching and support as we help you identify what it is that sets you apart, how to put words to the work that you do best, and how to ultimately get on those consult calls with people that say, "Hey, I read your website," or, "I heard about you from a Facebook post, and I know you're the therapist that I wanna work with."
I wanna see that happen for you. I wanna see that happen in your practice, and if Confident Copy is the right next step to make that happen for you, then we would absolutely love to get to support you beginning next week. So like I said, walkerstrategyco.com/waitlist if you're interested in that. If you're a Confident Copy alumni and you're listening, please submit your questions as it relates to your marketing. I love these opportunities to think alongside you and provide some coaching as you get out there and continue growing your caseload. So jump over to our form. If you're not sure of it, shoot us an email. But please do let us know what you are up to, alumni, as we can continue supporting you and cheering you on.
All right, y'all. Hope this one was helpful for you. I will be seeing you very soon as doors open for our Confident Copy cohort, and I'm always here cheering you on. See you on our next episode.
Resources & Links Mentioned:
Confident Copy Live waitlist: https://walkerstrategyco.com/waitlist
The Walker Strategy Co website: https://walkerstrategyco.com
Connect + Subscribe
Enjoying the podcast? Subscribe so you never miss an episode—and feel free to share it with a fellow therapist who’s building their private practice.
Explore more marketing support for therapists: The Walker Strategy Co website
About Marketing Therapy
Marketing Therapy is the podcast where therapists learn how to market their private practices without burnout, self-doubt, or sleazy tactics. Hosted by Anna Walker—marketing coach, strategist, and founder of Walker Strategy Co—each episode brings you clear, grounded advice to help you attract the right-fit, full-fee clients and grow a practice you feel proud of.
Rate & Review
If you’re enjoying Marketing Therapy, please consider leaving us a rating or review. This helps more therapists find the podcast (& avoid the marketing spiral).
