Why Therapists Should Take the Leap to Private Pay in 2024
If you're in the mental health industry, you've probably sensed the winds of change blowing a little stronger lately. In today’s world of Artificial Intelligence, big box therapy platforms, and economic turbulence, it can be difficult to feel confident about making any big decisions regarding the direction of your practice. But 2024 is seeming like it’ll be a standout year—one where therapists will want to seriously think about shifting towards private pay models.
Though certainly a big commitment, especially for those who have built their practices on a foundation of taking insurance, switching to a private pay practice can be beneficial for both clinicians and their clients. With less interference from insurance companies and more opportunities for client connection and specialized care, your practice may just be able to reach its full potential— all while giving you the personal and financial flexibility you’ve always dreamed of. So, let's dig into why 2024 might just be the perfect time for this transformative leap.
Riding the Wave of Change
The mental health industry’s landscape is vastly different than it was even a few years ago. Now, potential clients don’t rely on their insurance company’s directory to find a therapist—in fact, many prefer to take matters into their own hands these days. With a lot of folks seeking a therapist who specializes in something specific, clinicians are seeing referrals come in mostly from other channels.
Our recent State of the Industry Survey showed that of the 480 private practice owners who participated:
45% rank word of mouth as their top referral source
34% rank online directories like Psychology Today
35% rank their website as their number 1 or 2 source of new clients
This means that both networking and being able to write profile and website copy that clearly communicates your specialties are more important than ever. Here’s a free blog post that outlines how to do those things and more, if you’re interested:
The Ultimate Marketing Guide for Therapists:
How to Get More Therapy Clients with Less Effort
It’s clear that the old standard of finding a therapist through an insurance directory is certainly shifting in new directions—all the more reason to leave behind the precarity of dealing with insurance as a whole.
Putting Clients First
Another benefit of a private pay practice is the ability to put clients’ needs above the constraints of what insurance companies allow. For example, insurance companies often put a timeline on mental health care—insisting that a certain number of sessions should be enough to overcome whatever the client may be coming to you with. You, as a skilled clinician, know that’s not how healing works. By breaking free from insurance-driven models, you can prioritize clients' needs without compromise and take the reins in deciding what’s best for your clients.
Plus, the administrative hassles and bureaucracy involved in accepting insurance are a source of dread for many clinicians. Going fully private pay in your practice is a move that frees both you and your client from all the red tape. This independence will empower you to focus on what truly matters—the well-being of your clients.
Fostering Financial Flexibility
The thought of moving to a private pay model might create concerns about your ability to bring in clients initially. But here's the reality: in the last few years, there’s been an undeniable growth in appreciation for mental health services. More folks are prioritizing their mental well-being, and are willing to pay fees that align with how much they value quality care.
This shift in mindset creates opportunities for therapists to build sustainable practices that reflect what their time and expertise are actually worth. In fact, according to that same State of the Industry Survey, private pay practices make 10% more than insurance-based ones—even if their caseloads aren’t full. Once they are full, they’re generating 40% more revenue. So, if you feel hesitant about your ability to build a private pay caseload, don’t. There are clients out there looking for a therapist like you, who will be more than happy to pay what your services are worth.
Elevating Your Practice
You spent a lot of time in grad school (and possibly beyond) to become the expert you are today. You should be able to implement that expertise in the work you do in whatever format you’d like. However, if you wanted to start doing longer intensive sessions or another alternative format, a lot of insurance companies wouldn’t cover them. By going fully private pay, you can craft tailored treatment plans or packages for your clients. This personalized approach fosters meaningful progress and can give your practice that expert reputation it deserves.
Final Thoughts
As our industry continues to evolve and progress, there’s no doubt that we’ll see more therapists shift to private pay in 2024. For those folks, effective marketing strategies will play a key role in building their caseloads.
If you’re ready to take the next step and learn how to market your practice to attract private pay clients, check out this free workshop:
Whatever route you choose to go, we at Walker Strategy Co. are rooting for you!
If you’ve read this far, stay in touch in our public Facebook group.
